认罪认罚从宽背景下诱供的合法性控制——以侦查阶段为视角

The Legitimacy Control of Induced Confession in the Context of Leniency for Pleading Guilty——From the Perspective of Investigation Stage

传播影响力
本库下载频次:
本库浏览频次:
CNKI下载频次:0

归属学者:

马方

归属院系:

刑事侦查学院

作者:

马方1 ;张升魁

摘要:

认罪认罚从宽制度正式入法,标志着协商性司法在中国的进一步发展。其对于案件繁简分流、提升诉讼效率、优化司法资源配置具有重要作用。然而,认罪认罚案件中犯罪嫌疑人认罪供述在证明体系中的核心地位无疑印证了侦查机关对口供的需求。出于对非法证据排除规则的规避以及现行规定的利用,诱供成为现有制度下某些侦查人员获取犯罪嫌疑人认罪供述最便捷的手段。预防侦查机关非法取证行为,对认罪认罚从宽案件中的诱供进行规制,需要从诱供概念重构出发,通过其与认罪认罚从宽制度的内涵契合、不同语境下诱供内涵的审思,深入分析认罪认罚从宽制度背景下诱供的潜在风险,进而从权利义务告知程序重塑、录音录像制度规范化改造、值班律师权利细化、检察与监察二元监督体系构建等方面进行诱供的合法性控制,以期通过公权抑制与私权扶持实现侦查阶段适用认罪认罚从宽制度的规范化、法治化。

出版日期:

2020-11-20

学科:

诉讼法学

提交日期

2021-03-01

引用参考

马方;张升魁. 认罪认罚从宽背景下诱供的合法性控制——以侦查阶段为视角[J]. 山东警察学院学报,2020(06):59-68.

全文附件授权许可

知识共享许可协议-署名

  • dc.title
  • 认罪认罚从宽背景下诱供的合法性控制——以侦查阶段为视角
  • dc.contributor.author
  • 马方;张升魁
  • dc.contributor.author
  • MA Fang;ZHANG Shengkui;School of Criminal Investigation, Southwest University of Political Science and Law
  • dc.contributor.affiliation
  • 西南政法大学刑事侦查学院
  • dc.publisher
  • 山东警察学院学报
  • dc.publisher
  • Journal of Shandong Police College
  • dc.identifier.year
  • 2020
  • dc.identifier.issue
  • 06
  • dc.identifier.volume
  • v.32;No.174
  • dc.identifier.page
  • 59-68
  • dc.date.issued
  • 2020-11-20
  • dc.subject
  • 认罪认罚从宽;侦查阶段;诱供;潜在风险;控制路径
  • dc.subject
  • leniency for pleading guilty;investigation stage;induced confession;potential risks;control path
  • dc.description.abstract
  • 认罪认罚从宽制度正式入法,标志着协商性司法在中国的进一步发展。其对于案件繁简分流、提升诉讼效率、优化司法资源配置具有重要作用。然而,认罪认罚案件中犯罪嫌疑人认罪供述在证明体系中的核心地位无疑印证了侦查机关对口供的需求。出于对非法证据排除规则的规避以及现行规定的利用,诱供成为现有制度下某些侦查人员获取犯罪嫌疑人认罪供述最便捷的手段。预防侦查机关非法取证行为,对认罪认罚从宽案件中的诱供进行规制,需要从诱供概念重构出发,通过其与认罪认罚从宽制度的内涵契合、不同语境下诱供内涵的审思,深入分析认罪认罚从宽制度背景下诱供的潜在风险,进而从权利义务告知程序重塑、录音录像制度规范化改造、值班律师权利细化、检察与监察二元监督体系构建等方面进行诱供的合法性控制,以期通过公权抑制与私权扶持实现侦查阶段适用认罪认罚从宽制度的规范化、法治化。
  • dc.description.abstract
  • The system of leniency for pleading guilty has been formally incorporated into the law,which marks the further development of consultative justice in China. It plays an important role in diverting complicated cases,improving litigation efficiency and optimizing allocation of judicial resources. However,the core position of confession statement of suspects in the proof system in cases of pleading guilty undoubtedly confirms the demand of investigation organs for confession. In order to avoid exclusion rules of illegal evidence and make use of the current regulations,induced confession has become the most convenient means for some investigators to obtain suspects' confession under the existing system. In order to prevent investigation organs from obtaining evidence illegally and regulate induced confession in cases of leniency for pleading guilty,we need to conduct in-depth analysis on potential risks of induced confession under the background of the system of leniency for pleading guilty,and then control the legitimacy of induced confession from reshaping of rights and obligations notice procedures,standardization transformation of sound and video recording system,rights refinement of duty lawyer,construction of dual supervisory system of inspection and supervision,starting from the reconstruction of concept of induced confession,through the consideration of connotative integration with the system of leniency for pleading guilty and connotation of induced confession in different contexts,so as to realize standardization and rule of law of the system of leniency for pleading guilty at investigation stage through suppression of public power and support of private power.
  • dc.description.sponsorshipPCode
  • 17BFX005;DR2019Y021;2019ZAST027;20192019XZXS-110
  • dc.description.sponsorship
  • 国家社科基金项目“国家监察体制改革下职务犯罪调查权运行机制研究”(项目编号:17BFX005);国家毒品问题治理研究中心(毒品犯罪与对策研究中心)项目“认罪认罚从宽制度中诱供的合法性控制——以毒品犯罪案件为视角”[项目编号:DR(2019)Y021];重庆市“三特”行动计划治安学特色专业建设项目“公安机关提升‘小案’治理效能路径研究”(项目编号:2019ZAST027);西南政法大学2019年学生科研创新项目“自媒体时代重大社会安全风险的发现、化解与防范”(项目编号:2019XZXS-110)的阶段性研究成果
  • dc.description.sponsorshipsource
  • 国家社会科学基金
  • dc.identifier.CN
  • 37-1432/D
  • dc.identifier.issn
  • 1673-1565
  • dc.identifier.if
  • 0.578
  • dc.subject.discipline
  • D925.2
回到顶部